Twelve Provinces and the Politics of Anonymous Sources

Dr. Adil Zaman

Reports of a possible administrative restructuring have sparked a debate in Pakistan. Who is speaking for the government, and why are the details reaching the public through unnamed sources?

A story about redrawing Pakistan into twelve provinces has travelled quickly, from Ansar Abbasi’s reporting in The News to television debates and overseas headlines. His 8 November report mentioned a possible referendum and 28th Constitutional Amendment. His follow-up the next day suggested that any restructuring, if approved, would be implemented after the 2029 elections. The arrangement described in the reporting would divide Punjab into four provinces, Sindh into two, and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan into three each. The public has yet to see an approved government blueprint, draft amendment or map. A proposal is being discussed as though the country’s future boundaries are already taking shape.

The uncertainty is more than a technical detail. As The News reported on 30 October, Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal said the government was not drafting a 28th Amendment to create provinces and emphasised stronger local governments instead. Days later, the newspaper stories attributed a possible constitutional timetable to unnamed sources. In an interview with Geo News reported by Dawn, Defence Minister Khawaja Asif supported smaller administrative units while warning against divisions based on language, ethnicity or party advantage. An important debate is under way, but cabinet agreement on a twelve-province plan remains unconfirmed. Who is developing the proposal? Has it been discussed with provincial governments? If officials can speak openly about its advantages, why must its apparent timetable reach citizens through anonymous briefings?

There are two possible explanations, and it would be unfair to pretend we know which is correct. Abbasi may have obtained information independently from sources who cannot speak publicly. Uncovering plans before governments announce them is a legitimate part of journalism. Alternatively, individuals close to decision-making may be testing reactions by releasing selected details to a reporter instead of defending them at a press conference. Nothing in the available reporting proves deliberate leaking for that purpose. The first possibility is journalism holding power to account. The second would raise questions about officials using journalism to shape public opinion while avoiding responsibility for what they disclose.

The speed with which the story spread exposes a broader weakness in our public conversation. Bangladesh’s Daily Sun carried a Gulf News account of the proposal that included Khawaja Asif’s remarks. As a report travels from one outlet to another, its repetition can create the appearance of confirmation even when publications are largely describing the same original claims. Maps appear, talk shows assemble panels and people argue about who will gain or lose. Journalists should ask what has been verified, what reflects a minister’s preference and what still rests on an unnamed source’s account.

The underlying reform deserves serious consideration in its own right. In his January 2026 SouthAsia essay “Mapping a New Pakistan”, demographer Dr. Mehtab S. Karim advocated twenty smaller provinces or administrative units, together with power at the local level. His proposal differs substantially from the reported twelve-province formula, but both respond to the same question. How can a large and unevenly developed country bring decisions, money and services closer to citizens? These competing models show that the number of provinces remains open to debate. Smaller provinces might reduce administrative distance. They might also add elected offices, bureaucracies and financial disputes while leaving authority concentrated in provincial capitals. Genuine decentralisation depends on who gains the power to make decisions and spend public money.

Changing provincial boundaries requires a constitutional process. Article 239 of Pakistan’s Constitution requires the support of at least two-thirds of the total membership of each house of Parliament and, where a province’s boundaries would change, at least two-thirds of the total membership of its provincial assembly. A nationwide referendum could gauge public opinion, but those legislative approvals would still be required. How would the NFC Award be distributed, how would water shares be protected, and who would inherit provincial debts, employees and assets? Elected representatives, constitutional experts and affected communities should have a say in those decisions.

Reporters sometimes need anonymous sources to reveal matters that powerful institutions prefer to keep hidden. Responsible journalism should explain, where it can safely do so, why a source is unnamed, seek independent verification and make clear which claims remain unconfirmed. The larger duty falls on the government. If a restructuring plan exists, it should publish the rationale, options, costs and consultation process. If no plan exists, officials should say so consistently and explain the status of the proposals. Abbasi was entitled to report the story. The question is why citizens must piece together the future of their federation from scattered statements, unattributed details and speculative maps. A country’s political map should be debated in public, where citizens can see the proposals and question those who put them forward.